Nevada Supremes rule in favor of judge and against discipline process

nevada supreme court bldg
Wikimedia CC BY-SA 3.0 by Coolcaesar
nevada supreme court bldg
Wikimedia CC BY-SA 3.0 by Coolcaesar

Judges in Nevada cannot be forced to answer questions under oath about potential discipline matters before being formally charged with a violation.  

The Nevada Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the Judicial Discipline Commission lacks authority to force Las Vegas Justice of the Peace Melanie Tobiasson to answer written questions under oath before the Commission has filed formal charges.  

The Supreme Court, which has original jurisdiction over the Discipline Commission, heard argument on the writ in April.

“To be clear, a judge owes an ethical duty to ‘cooperate and be candid and honest’ with the Commission. …. But nothing in our statutes or the Commission’s procedural rules authorize the Commission to demand that a judge answer questions under oath at this pre-adjudicative stage of the disciplinary process,” the Supreme Court justices wrote.

The complaint filed by the commission against Tobiasson alleges she violated judicial ethics rules by speaking publicly about her contention that some law enforcement officers are protecting pimps and prostitutes, who are in turn targeting the daughters of police and judges for the sex trade.  

Tobiasson called foul last year, criticizing a process that renders the commission complainant, prosecutor, judge and jury.  Her attorney, William Terry, alleged the judicial discipline process violates the due process rights of Nevada judges.  

In a “friend of the court” brief, an association of Justices of the Peace, the Nevada Judges of Limited Jurisdiction (NJLJ), wrote:

“In essence, the Commission is demanding that a judge provide the evidence that the Commission may use to support a final finding of reasonable probability and the filing of a formal statement of charges and then using that evidence against the judge in a formal hearing.”

Judicial Discipline Commission Executive Director Paul Deyhle did not respond to the Current’s request for comment.

Tobiasson declined to comment on her next steps.

Dana Gentry
Reporter | Dana Gentry is a native Las Vegan and award-winning investigative journalist. She is a graduate of Bishop Gorman High School and holds a Bachelor's degree in Communications from the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. Gentry began her career in broadcasting as an intern at Channel 8, KLAS-TV. She later became a reporter at Channel 8, working with Las Vegas TV news legends Bob Stoldal and the late Ned Day. Gentry left her reporting job in 1985 to focus on motherhood. She returned to TV news in 2001 to launch "Face to Face with Jon Ralston" and the weekly business programs In Business Las Vegas and Vegas Inc, which she co-anchored with Jeff Gillan. Dana is the mother of four adult children, three cats, three dogs and a cockatoo.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here